A Case Study on the Practice of Pretrial Services and Risk Assessment in Three Cities

Group: Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute

URL: http://www.dccrimepolicy.org/images/Pretrial-Comparative-Final-Report_1.pdf

Description

This report compares three pretrial agencies—Washington, D.C., New York City, and Baltimore—and discusses their practice of pretrial services and programs, with a particular focus on risk assessment. DCPI researchers identify several unique attributes of the District of Columbia’s Pretrial Service Agency, including its focus on public safety, implementation of formal assessments of flight risk, and lack of reliance on monetary bail. They conclude that PSA’s pretrial risk assessment is more comprehensive than in the other two agencies because it is both designed to inform the use of a broad range of pretrial treatment and supervision options and is focused on helping to reduce and manage the risk to public safety posed by pretrial defendants.

Tags

courts, pretrial, risk assessment, pretrial services, bail

Other Attributes
Sub-location
Statewide
Categories
Sectors (Govt, Non-Profit, etc)
Non-Profit
Formats
PDF
Location in resource
N/A
Internet Available?
Yes
Has population data?
No
Mappable?
No
Updated?
No
Frequency
N/A
Year(s) of Publication
2011

More like this

State/Location Categories Title Group Year(s) of Publication URL
District of Columbia Courts/Pretrial Pre-Trial Detention of Dangerous and Violent Defendants Following Passage of the Omnibus Public Safety Justice Amendment Act of 2009 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Financial/Courts Pretrial Service Agency Performance Budget Pretrial Services Agency for the District of Columbia 2016 Direct Link
District of Columbia Courts/Pretrial Pretrial Services Agency for the District of Columbia's 2014-2018 Human Capital Strategic Plan Pretrial Services Agency for the District of Columbia 2012-2016 Direct Link
District of Columbia Courts/Pretrial Pretrial Services Agency for the District of Columbia's 2014-2018 Strategic Plan Pretrial Services Agency for the District of Columbia 2014-2018 Direct Link
District of Columbia Courts/Pretrial Performance Measures Pretrial Services Agency for the District of Columbia 2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Recidivism Public Safety Indicators Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2004-2012 Direct Link
New Mexico Courts/Pretrial Assessment of the Second Judicial District Court Pretrial Services Office New Mexico Sentencing Commission 2014 Direct Link
District of Columbia Courts/Pretrial Adult Drug Test Statistics Pretrial Services Agency for the District of Columbia 1996-Present Direct Link
District of Columbia Courts/Pretrial Juvenile Drug Test Statistics Pretrial Services Agency for the District of Columbia 1996-Present Direct Link
New Mexico Courts/Pretrial Assessment of the Second Judicial District Court Pretrial Services Office: Report in Brief New Mexico Sentencing Commission 2014 Direct Link
California Miscellaneous/State-Specific Topics Managing Jail Populations to Enhance Public Safety: Assessing and Managing Risk in the Post-Realignment Era Stanford University 2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections DYRS Risk Assessment and Structured Decision‐Making Validation Study & System Assessment Summary Report Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Administration,Courts Human Capital Strategic Plan Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia 2010-2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Miscellaneous/State-Specific Topics The District of Columbia Mayor's Focused Improvement Area Initiative: A Review of Past Practice Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2011 Direct Link
California Courts/Pretrial Assessing the Impact of Bail on CA's Jail Population Public Policy Institute of CA 2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections Blue Ribbon Commission on Youth Safety and Juvenile Justice Reform in the District of Columbia Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2001 Direct Link
Kansas Courts/Pretrial Annual Report U.S. Probation and Pretrial Services District of Kansas 2003-2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Reentry Summary of Focus Group with Ex-Prisoners in the District: Ingredients for Successful Reintegration Urban Institute Justice Policy Center 2001 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services Performance Plans and Reports Office of the City Administrator 2008-2015 Direct Link
Louisiana Courts/Pretrial Bail Bond Reduction in Orleans Criminal District Court Metropolitan Crime Commission 2005 Direct Link
District of Columbia Financial/Corrections Agency Financial Reports Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia 2014 Direct Link
South Dakota Law Enforcement/Performance Measures CALEA On-Site Assessment Report Rapid City Police Department 2010-2013 Direct Link
Texas Juvenile Justice/Corrections Customer Service Survey Texas Juvenile Justice Department 2004 Direct Link
District of Columbia Law Enforcement/Crime Data Public Safety and Justice in the District of Columbia: 2005 - 2011 Criminal Justice Coordinating Council 2014 Direct Link
District of Columbia Miscellaneous/State-Specific Topics Meta-Analytic Cost-Benefit Estimates Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2011 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections Agency Progress Report 2014 Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2014 Direct Link
District of Columbia Miscellaneous/State-Specific Topics The District of Columbia Mayor's Focused Improvement Area Initiative: Review of the Literature Relevant to Collaborative Crime Reduction Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2011 Direct Link
Minnesota Juvenile Justice/Courts Juvenile Detention Alternative Initiative: Validation of the Risk Assessment Instrument Fourth Judicial District Research Division 2009 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Recidivism Measuring Recidivism in the District of Columbia Criminal Justice Coordinating Council 2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Treatment Programs Addressing Co-occurring Mental Health and Substance Abuse Disorders in the Criminal Justice System: Guiding Principles and DC Practices Urban Institute Justice Policy Center 2004 Direct Link
District of Columbia Law Enforcement/Other Programs Strategic Plan for a Collaborative Neighborhood-Based Crime Prevention Initiative Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2011 Direct Link
National Courts/Pretrial Developing a National Pretrial Risk Assessment Model Arnold Foundation 2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Administration,Courts Annual Employee Survey Report Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia 2014 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Administration,Courts HSPD-12 Implementation Report Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia 2015 Direct Link
Maryland Courts/Pretrial Report of the Bail System Task Force Maryland Courts 2007 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections Capital Change: A Process Evaluation of Washington DC's Secure Juvenile Placement Reform Vera Institute for Justice 2011 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections DYRS 2012 Mid-Year Public Safety Report Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2012 Direct Link
Minnesota Courts/Pretrial Validation of the New 2007 Pretrial Scale Fourth Judicial District Research Division 2010 Direct Link
Utah Courts/Pretrial Evaluation of Pretrial Services: Final Report University of Utah 2010 Direct Link
District of Columbia Law Enforcement/Performance Measures Track DMPSJ Track DC 2014-2015 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Reentry Reentry Report Criminal Justice Coordinating Council 2011 Direct Link
Maryland Juvenile Justice/Delinquents Assessing School Attendance Problems and Truancy Intervention in Maryland: A Synthesis of Evidence from Baltimore City and the Lower Eastern Shore University of Maryland Institute for Governmental Service and Research 2011 Direct Link
Minnesota Courts/Pretrial Fourth Judicial District Pretrial Evaluation: Scale Validation Study Fourth Judicial District Research Division 2006 Direct Link
Ohio Courts/Pretrial Creation and Validation of the Ohio Risk Assessment System Office of Criminal Justice Services, University of Cincinnati 2009 Direct Link
Alaska Law Enforcement/Crime Analytic Programs Public Safety and Policing in Alaska Native Villages: Component Three of Alaska Public Safety Project University of Alaska Anchorage Justice Center 1995 Direct Link
Massachusetts Corrections/Probation & Parole Housing After Prison: The Massachusetts Parole Board Model Massachusetts Parole Board 2008 Direct Link
Maryland Juvenile Justice/Corrections 2013 Gap Analysis Maryland Department of Juvenile Services 2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Law Enforcement/Administration Promising Practices of the District of Columbia Metropolitan Police Department Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2011 Direct Link
North Carolina Courts/Pretrial Pretrial Service Programs in North Carolina: A Process and Impact Assessment North Carolina Governor's Crime Commission 2007 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Treatment Programs The Costs and Benefits of Community-Based Substance Abuse Treatment in the District of Columbia Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Financial/Corrections Community Supervision Program Performance Budget Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia 2016 Direct Link
Montana Courts/Pretrial Risk Assessment Instrument Validation Report Montana Board of Crime Control 2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Administration,Courts Strategic Plan Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia 2014-2018 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Reentry Returning From Prison to Washington, D.C. Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia Unknown Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Status Offenses Interim Report on the Truancy Court Diversion Program in the District of Columbia, 2011-12 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2011-2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Status Offenses Evaluation of the Truancy Court Diversion Program in the District of Columbia, 2011-12 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2011-2012 Direct Link
Hawaii Corrections/Recidivism Recidivism Update Reports Interagency Council on Intermediate Sanctions 2008-2013 Direct Link
Washington Law Enforcement/Police Encounters Community Assessment of Policing and Public Safety in the City of Seattle Seattle Office of Policy and Management 2007 Direct Link
Minnesota Juvenile Justice/Courts Validation of the Fourth Judicial District Juvenile Courtroom Risk Assessment Instrument Fourth Judicial District Research Division 2013 Direct Link
California Corrections/Inmates California's Changing Prison Population Public Policy Institute of CA 2013 Direct Link
Washington Corrections/Probation & Parole New Risk Instrument for Offenders Improves Classification Decisions Washington State Institute for Public Policy 2009 Direct Link
Washington Courts/Equal Justice Research Study "A Study on Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Superior Court Bail and Pretrial Detention Practices in Washington" Final Report Washington Administrative Office of the Courts 1997 Direct Link
Minnesota Juvenile Justice/Corrections Minnesota Juvenile Diversion: A Summary of Statewide Practices and Programming Minnesota Department of Public Safety Office of Justice Programs 2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Crime/Violent Crime Murder Analysis: A Study of Homicides in the District of Columbia Metropolitan Police Department 2001 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections DYRS 2012 Public Safety Summary Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2012 Direct Link
Nebraska Crime/Violent Crime Nebraska Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System Reports Department of Health and Human Services 1999-2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Crime/Sex Crimes Sex Abuse in the District of Columbia, 2000 - 2009 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2000-2009 Direct Link
Ohio Law Enforcement/Police Encounters Understanding Best Search and Seizure Practices University of Cincinnati 2007 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections Annual Performance Report Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2011-2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections Consent Decree Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 1986 Direct Link
Washington Corrections/Recidivism Washington State Recidivism Trends: Adult Offenders Released From Prison, 1990 – 2006 Washington State Institute for Public Policy 2011 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Status Offenses Evaluation of the Pilot Program of the Truancy Case Management Partnership Initiative in the District of Columbia, 2011-12 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2011-2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Corrections DYRS 2013 Mid-Year Public Safety Report Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Other Programs Delinquent Youth Committed to the Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2004-2011 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2004-2011 Direct Link
Massachusetts Corrections/Reentry From Incarceration to Community: A Roadmap to Improving Prisoner Reentry and System Accountability in Massachusetts Community Resources for Justice Crime and Justice Institute 2004 Direct Link
Hawaii Corrections/Recidivism Hawaii Recidivism Study – A Three-Year Baseline Follow-Up Analysis Interagency Council on Intermediate Sanctions 1998-2008 Direct Link
Montana Courts/Pretrial The Montana Pre-Adjudicatory Detention Risk Assessment Instrument Montana Board of Crime Control 2014 Direct Link
District of Columbia CSOSA Community Supervision Improvements Since 2002 Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia Unknown Direct Link
Oregon Juvenile Justice/Corrections OYA Nuisance Incident Risk Assessment Oregon Youth Authority 2011 Direct Link
Oregon Juvenile Justice/Corrections OYA Violent Incident Risk Assessment Oregon Youth Authority 2011 Direct Link
Washington Courts/Pretrial Thurston County Superior Court Pretrial Risk Assessment Washington State Center for Court Research 2011 Direct Link
Utah Courts/Pretrial Pretrial Release Risk Study, Validation, & Scoring: Final Report University of Utah 2013 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Administration,Courts CSOSA Service Contract Inventory and Analysis Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia 2011-2014 Direct Link
District of Columbia Juvenile Justice/Other Programs DC YouthLink: Investing in Youth and Communities to Promote Public Safety Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services 2013 Direct Link
New Mexico Courts/Sentencing Research Publications and Current Projects of the New Mexico Sentencing Commission New Mexico Sentencing Commission 2008 Direct Link
District of Columbia Courts/Other Programs The Costs and Benefits of Functional Family Therapy for Washington, D.C. Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2012 Direct Link
Louisiana Miscellaneous/State-Specific Topics Proposals for New Orleans' Criminal Justice System: Best Practices to Advance Public Safety and Justice Vera Institute of Justice 2007 Direct Link
Hawaii Corrections/Reentry Assessment Data Brief: Screening for Risk of Re-Offending: Hawaii’s Proxy Scale and Level of Service Inventory Interagency Council on Intermediate Sanctions 2005 Direct Link
Minnesota Law Enforcement/Crime Data District Council Reports Saint Paul Police Department 2011-2015 Direct Link
District of Columbia Crime/Property Crime Motor Vehicle Theft in the District of Columbia Patterns and Trends, 2000-2009 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2000-2009 Direct Link
District of Columbia Law Enforcement/Administration Police Service Areas (PSAs) Neighborhood Info DC, Urban Institute, National Neighborhood Indicators Partnership 2012 Direct Link
Nebraska Juvenile Justice/Courts An Evaluation of Substance Abuse Screening and Risk Assessment in Nebraska’s Juvenile Justice System University of Nebraska, CSULA 2004 Direct Link
National Courts/Public Legal Services Indigent Defense Services in the United States, FY 2008–2012-Updated Bureau of Justice Statistics 2014 Direct Link
District of Columbia Miscellaneous/State-Specific Topics Demographic Trends in the District of Columbia, 2000-2009 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2000-2009 Direct Link
District of Columbia Law Enforcement/Administration Maps of MPD's Police Districts and PSAs Metropolitan Police Department N/A Direct Link
District of Columbia Law Enforcement/Crime Data Small Number of Blocks Account for Lots of Crime in D.C. Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2010 Direct Link
National Courts/Public Legal Services Indigent Defense Services In The United States, FY 2008–2012-Updated Bureau of Justice Statistics 2008-2012 Direct Link
District of Columbia Corrections/Inmates Distribution of District of Columbia Inmates house in a BOP Facility by State and Gender Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency for the District of Columbia Last month Direct Link
District of Columbia Financial/Corrections,Financial/Courts,Financial/Law Enforcement Public Employee Salary Information District of Columbia Department of Human Resources Past quarter Direct Link
District of Columbia Miscellaneous/State-Specific Topics Foreclosures and Crime in the District of Columbia, 2003-2010 Urban Institute District of Columbia Crime Policy Institute 2012 Direct Link